I have finished the first season of Heroes and I’m honestly thinking of just stopping there and pretending the last minute or so didn’t happen because sadly the main reason I didn’t remember a lot from season 1 is because it was good. The bad from the show stuck with me the most and that’s season 2-3. Season 4 isn’t actually that bad, it’s structured closer to season one’s “save the cheerleader, save the world” but, you know, minus the cheerleader. However it’s still not that great because of the consistent issue that it still TRIES TO REDEEM A SERIAL KILLER.
Look, I love Sylar and a lot of his characterization. I love how truly terrifying he is in each scene. Zachary Quinto is great does great with villains, but he honestly should have been killed off at the end of season 1, at the latest, the end of season 2 because it got tiring watching the mental gymnastics done to justify not killing him, especially when he was the “reformed” serial killer and then people are shocked when he turns around and kills them. If they wanted to keep him around, he needed to stay the villain, and people really needed to stop thinking he might get better because he’s serial killer. While his intentions are to gain powers, it becomes very clear that he enjoys killing, and by the ticking music that plays to indicate his presence, not only is it there to reference his past as clock maker, but it also a manifestation of how he picks his victims, the switch in his brain that says kill this specific person. He can’t resist. I bet his CT scans have a lot in common with serial killers. The only place he should have been was dead or locked up, or roaming around as a dangerous serial killer, instead of trying to reform him.
And then there’s Mohinder. One of my favorite characters, and one of the main things I love about him is that he’s ambitious, but never at the expense of other people. He never seeks power, but rather knowledge. Two thing are established about his character’s personality, one he’s not stupid, and two he’s not power hungry, and in one storyline where he objects himself with an unstable formula, both of those are thrown out the window.
And Peter Petrelli, I noticed that he was kinda the Bonnie Bennett, not in treatment obviously, but in the fact that they both possibility most powerful of their respective series and due to such both are often de-powered. I understand it’s hard to write an OP character, but constantly de-powered them isn’t the answer. It’s just frustrating and kinda lazy, but at least when Heroes de-powered Peter they stayed pretty consistent. He didn’t just become powerful again when he was needed, he just had “a” power. Bonnie powers were just there to be used.
Ah how could I forget Nikki and DL. You know I literally forgot DL and his power. Why? Because they kill him off too quickly and honestly in kinda a dumb way. I will never understand why the writers kept fatally injuring a character who can phase through walls with bullets. Like I get that he’s not always in that form but one consistent thing with the powers is that they always kick in for survival. Why is he exempt from this.
But overall the main reason I’m calling it quits here is because the later seasons just aren’t written with the same amount of care as the first season. The first season I could tell they had everything thought through, every scene had a purpose. The rest of the series doesn’t have that luxury, mostly due to the writers strike that caused them to have to throw out most of what they had planned for season 2 (and why there’s only 11 episodes that season), but also because they had to throw out things they couldn’t get back.
Edit: I wrote this a while back and I’m just posting it know because I want to clean up my drafts (there are so many 🤤).